If you’re not a regular at the Carnival of Personal Finance already, check it out. It’s a collection of some really great personal finance posts from many good blogs. It also features a post of mine from last week on value investing. If you’re new to Invest Wisdom, I hope you enjoy the site, and subscribe if you like it!
——
Berkshire Hathaway’s annual meeting is always part-carnival, part-symposium for the world’s greatest investors. Several years ago, Warren Buffett, the company’s leader, dubbed it “our capitalist’s version of Woodstock”, and the name has stuck.
Thousands flock for the weekend near the company’s headquarters in Omaha, Nebraska, and Buffett talks on a wide range of subjects, pertaining to the company specifically and the economy as a whole. It’s easy to get lost in the round-the-clock coverage of the Oracle of Omaha’s yearly salon, but I’ve culled from various news reports five things that Buffett said that I think average investors should pay attention to.
1. Buffett thinks inflation will go up. To pay for the trillions of dollars in fiscal stimulus being pumped into the economy, the government will have two choices: raise taxes or print money (that is, let inflation rise). Because politicians loathe the backlash of tax hikes, Buffett thinks they’re likely to pay for their spending the backhanded way, by devaluing the dollar.
What to do: If you think Buffett’s right, the most traditional defenses against inflation are Treasury Inflation-Protected Securities (a.k.a. TIPS), I Bonds, and commodities like gold and oil. Stocks also aren’t a bad investment, since their earnings should reflect rising prices, but depending on the business, companies can have trouble passing costs through. I’d go with TIPS or I Bonds because they’re designed to protect against inflation. Commodities, on the other hand, can be extremely volatile, no matter what inflation is actually doing. If you do go the commodity route, stick with ETFs rather than buy the actual materials, which can be hard to buy and sell.
2. He still thinks his equity put options will make money. Don’t worry about the technicalities of an equity put option. Basically, Buffett insured some investors against the possibility that major stock indexes would be down when the contracts expire between 2019 and 2028. At the meeting, he expressed confidence that those contracts would be pure profit for Berkshire. In other words, he firmly believes the stock market will have moved up and past the insured values in the next 10 to 20 years.
What to do: Buffett has always been candid about his feelings, whether it be on his own company or on the market as a whole. In fact, Buffett mentioned that he thinks he’ll probably lose money in his credit default contracts that expire in the next five years. In other words, he thinks he underestimated how many companies would go bankrupt in the near term. But Buffett’s bullish on the longterm rise of the stock market. For you, that probably means you shouldn’t hunker down for another “lost decade” as we had in the last 10 years and avoid stocks. If he’s right, it could cost you bigtime.
3) Buffett’s not planning to buy back shares of his own company. And more important, he thinks that Berkshire Hathaway’s $92,500 share price is not “demonstrably below” a conservative estimate of the company’s value, despite being down about 30% from a year ago.
What to do: On its own, Buffett’s basically saying he can’t make the case that his company is at a bargain basement price. But we can extrapolate a little to determine what price-to-earnings ratio Buffett views as conservative. In the May issue of Money, I (along with an unnamed money manager very familiar with the company) came up with an estimate of about $103,600 for Berkshire’s intrinsic value. To do that, we looked at the earnings of the companies that Berkshire held and multiplied them by a P/E below the average P/E of the sector.
So, for example, Buffett’s utilities companies earned about $1,100 per share in 2008. The average P/E of a utilities company was 10. So to be conservative, we multiplied the earnings by a P/E of 8 to get an estimated value of $8,800 per share of Berkshire’s utilities companies.
The fact that our estimate ends up above Buffett’s “conservative” estimate for his own company means that his “conservative” P/Es must be below the ones we used, even after factoring in the 11% decline in earnings that Berkshire suffered in the first quarter.
That would mean, if you wanted to buy a company at a discount that Buffett considers to be very low you’d want utilities companies with P/Es below 8, and financials and retailers with P/Es below 10. That’s not a perfect guideline (another popular way of valuing financials is a price-to-book ratio, for example) but it is helpful for a general understanding of how conservative Buffett is being when building in a margin of safety for his stock purchases. And the answer is: very conservative.
4. He sold $5 million worth of Treasury bills for more than $5 million. In other words, whoever bought those Treasuries from Buffett (on Dec. 18, 2008) was willing to get a negative yield on those Treasury bills. For the record, he sold it for only $90.97 over $5 million, but it’s still extraordinary that investors fear risk so much that they’d take a negative yield in the only no-risk investment out there.
What to do: In his annual report, Buffett wrote this gem:
When the financial history of this decade is written, it will surely speak of the Internet bubble of the late 1990s and the housing bubble of the early 2000s. But the U.S. Treasury bond bubble of late 2008 may be regarded as almost equally extraordinary.
If you hold Treasury bonds directly, although they’re probably worth a lot right now, it would be difficult and costly to try to sell them to someone else unless you own a whole lot of them. On the other hand, if you have a lot of money tied up in long-term government bond mutual funds, now might be the time to get out of those and into something more fairly valued.
I’d personally invest it in a stock mutual fund, but if you want to stay with the risk-free route, TIPS or a mutual fund investing in them would seem to be a better deal. Even those with a regular old bond index fund should be wary. Vanguard’s Total Bond Index fund, for example, has 24% of its holdings in U.S. Treasuries. That doesn’t mean Vanguard’s doing something wrong; it’s just the nature of an index. But it’s one potential time bomb I’d keep your eye on.
5. Buffett wouldn’t buy U.S. newspapers at any price. He says he sees unending losses for the entire industry and no business model that could save them.
What to do: This probably doesn’t mean much to you (other than the death of your local newspaper). For me, a print journalist, it means I should be looking for a new job.
Thanks for reading.
- Joe Light